Constraints on LTV as a macroprudential tool: A precautionary tale

Authors: José García-Montalvo and Josep M. Raya

Oxford Economic Papers, Vol. 70, No 3, 821-845, July, 2018

The introduction of limits or regulatory penalties on high LTV ratios for residentialmortgages is one of the most frequently used tools of macroprudential policy. The available evidence seems to indicate that this instrument can reduce the feedback loop between credit and house prices. In this paper, we show that these constraints on LTV ratios, used by Spanish banking regulators before the onset of the housing crisis of 2008, did not prevent that feedback loop. In the Spanish case, the fact that appraisal companies were mostly owned by banks led to a situation in which the LTV limits were used to generate appraisal values adjusted to the needs of the clients, rather than trying to appropriately represent the value of the property. This tendency towards over-appraisals produced important externalities in terms of a higher than otherwise demand for housing, and intensification of the feedback loop between credit and house prices.

This paper originally appeared as Barcelona GSE Working Paper 1008